Discussion about this post

User's avatar
S...'s avatar

At the end you say “Ellul says”. This is the most succinct summation of the crux of the issue I’ve run across. I meditate on this, also, almost daily. It’s a question of “is it better to die on your feet, or live on your knees”. Echoes of ghost dances and iron shirts. It is quite clear to me that to stand against, in any meaningful way, is to suffer defeat. The power differential is almost unfathomable. I recently traveled through Diné land. The whole time I had a sense of seeing people who had been living this dilemma for generations, and persist anyway. I would not blame them in any way, at all, for not sharing their hard earned wisdom with the moderns slamming face first into the same dilemma.

Expand full comment
jacquelyn sauriol's avatar

In a documentary I watched on Native lives in Canada, a very old man could be heard to say that once they separated people from nature, we were broken. Our separation from nature (illusary though it is) began even longer ago than the computer age, probably the industrial age (roughly 1750-1850) and the post industrial age that followed, where we were driven into cities in search of money, essentially. I don't know what to call the age we are in now except for post apocolyptic with a dash of new agrarian as some people flee 'back' to the countryside, those that have the means. A long power outtage and pop goes the weasel.

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts